After a game today I realised I need to make some hnages. So i have come up with these three lists. Basically I need to know which one is better. Points costs are not exact, it about the principle after all.

List 1:
Noble in chariot
Dispell caddie
Noble on DS
16 Spearelves
5 DR (RXB)
5 DR (RXB)
12 EXES
1 COC
1 COC
1 Hydra
10 WE

List 2:
Noble in chariot
Dispell caddie
16 Spearelves
5 DR (RXB)
5 DR (RXB)
12 EXES
1 COC
1 COC
1 Hydra
10 WE
10 RXB elves

List 3:
Noble in chariot
Dispell caddie
20 Spearelves
5 DR (RXB)
5 DR (RXB)
12 EXES
1 COC
1 COC
1 Hydra
12 Corsairs
8 shades

Please help me, please!

I like them all but I would go for the 1st list.
Why you may ask:
Because you have an extra combat hero.
It is more MSu to me.
It does not ave RXBs which will not make an impact with how little shooting you have.
It does have somthing to cut apart cavalary.
Whitch elves are cool in that amount.
It can do more damage quickly
It is quicker.

By the way I think it is a good idea you changed as if a list is not working it will not work for you most of the time.

The list worked, not just against every one :). t would deal a speedy dealth to small comact elite, tough armoured foes. BUT!

Hit anythign like an elf, empire, skavenand indeed a dwarf gun line then splat I couldn't even hope for a draw :(

But this should sort it.