Title: SOTW II - VOTE
Azarath Angel - March 19, 2006 04:39 AM (GMT)
Entrants may NOT vote. Vote will be open until Wed, March 22nd.stephen griffiths

Mason

Doomprinny

Palglo

Matthias

Good luck to all entrants.
BustaMo - March 19, 2006 07:16 AM (GMT)
Wow I have to say Matthias. Sure the white text was a bit hard to read at first, but the saying was awesome and just the whole image is like..Whoa. Nice job Matthias!
Drift - March 19, 2006 09:37 AM (GMT)
My vote goes to Mason.
They're all good, but the only two that appealed to me were Doomprinny and Mason, and although Doomprinny's is designed well, the choice in colour definately didn't help my choice...
Stephanie - March 19, 2006 10:09 AM (GMT)
Hm hard one,
SG this is a really good sig, you used a good picture this time instead of a google search one hehe joking. Well done.
Sora looks like he's under water wason :S
I agree with Drift Doom, the colour is a bit boring and lifeless which I think sora has a lot of.
Palgo's is pretty but a bit bland.
So I voted for Matthias, I think it needs a border but its very pretty and I like the colour choice, it suits both characters and I didnt bother to read the text but it looks pretty anyway. Nice work.
Trance_Kuja - March 19, 2006 02:17 PM (GMT)
My vote goes to Matthias, a really nice sig there.
Melancholy Rockit - March 19, 2006 02:20 PM (GMT)
my vote went to Mason
I like the blue, what can i say
but they were all pretty good
also, it was weird seeing the same renders in a sig battle, just saying
viper - March 19, 2006 08:01 PM (GMT)
i vote for Doomprinny
i love the effect of the girl in the flag
Good job :)
Azarath Angel - March 20, 2006 11:54 PM (GMT)
I guess I get to vote cuz Im not in this one.
stephen griffiths, the positioning of the render is quirky and well suited, however the static background and plain text are just average, imho. 7.5/10
Mason, what can I say? I love this sig. The cool blue suits the render and the wind effect is very interesting. I , however, do not like the style of the text, but it is blended well. 9/10
Doomprinny, this is easily one of your better sigs. The effect with Kairi in the flag is stellar. However I have the same problem with this is as your others. The color scheme is very simplistic and your text is hard to read. 8/10
Palglo, I am liking the way you approched this sig. The simplicity is unusualy nice looking, and the sig is not crowded at all. The style of the text is very gorgeous, but the renders are the sigs flaw. 7.5/10
Matthias, your sig is simply beautiful. The sig as a very ethereal feel to it. The sig is subtle, yet eye-catching at the same time. My only problem with it is that bar line you have going across the bottom. 9.5/10
Well as you all can see by the scores, Matthias gets my vote, and the win. Congrats to Matthias and all the other entrants. SOTW III will begin this wed.
Palglo - March 20, 2006 11:58 PM (GMT)
Gar not one vote lol oh well, least i wasnt the only 1. I wouldnt have voted for me anyway but meh.
Anyway congrats Matthias, and everybody else.
*walks off and sulks*
BustaMo - March 21, 2006 12:10 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Palglo @ Mar 20 2006, 06:58 PM) |
Gar not one vote lol oh well, least i wasnt the only 1. I wouldnt have voted for me anyway but meh.
Anyway congrats Matthias, and everybody else. *walks off and sulks* |
Hmm maybe it was because you made a topic about it aside from the SOTW competition and gave people a chance to see it. Then whenit came time for SOTW they wanted something new, just an idea maybe for next time just incase. Ya might want to wait til the voting to hear what people think of the sig. Nice job everyone though
Congrats Matthias! Awesome sig.
Doomprinny - March 21, 2006 12:57 AM (GMT)
Aww I never win
I need that.. perfection
anyway comgrats Mathias :)
TheMissingCloud - March 21, 2006 01:42 AM (GMT)
Wow Matthias that is nice. Takes two great pics and adds a nice BG and cool quote to it. Palago's was cool too with the different colors, but it could have used something more. I liked the darker atmosphere around Doomprinny's and the blue in Masons. C'mon SG I know your capable of more than just a pic with Sora and a nice red background better than my sig though ie nothing.
Ross - March 21, 2006 02:05 AM (GMT)
Doomprinny the sig you entered here was the best I've seen you make, and you will only improve with practice!
My vote went to Matthias for the really awesome sig. Mason would be in second but the colors turned me off a little, they look a little strong but other then that good job.
All other competitors, great job keep practicing!
Matthias - March 21, 2006 02:15 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Doomprinny @ Mar 20 2006, 06:57 PM) |
Aww I never win
I need that.. perfection
anyway comgrats Mathias :) |
Actually, this is the first Sig Battle I've ever won so don't worry. You're a lot better than I am at this so I know you'll win one soon. Thanks for all the compliments and comments everyone!
Mason - March 21, 2006 02:00 PM (GMT)
Congrats Dude, well earned win ;)
Aweosme entries all.