:gryffindor: :hufflepuff: :slytherin: :ravenclaw:

[FONT=Geneva] The first four books were absolute masterpieces , but because of their [COLOR=blue]greatness, [COLOR=red]were our expectations too high for book 5? There are numerous pieces of fanfiction all over the net; people write what they think will happen. After reading the [COLOR=green]Order of the Phoenix, I have to admit, i was not as satisfied as i thought i would be. As I read about the parchment and the pen that slashed your skin, i started to believe it a littler far-fetched. Don't you think? However, it was still very good. I can't explain all my feelings for the book in words.

Tell me what you think =]

Book 5 for me was very very good it was interesting and very sad at the end i really liked it.

yeah i loved order of the phoenix...i love it the most of the whole series so far, maybe its because so much happens and so many things are explained, along with giving u more things to think about.

OOTP for me was the best so far. It's got good competition from POA but OOTP was so refreshing. It explained so much and left even more questions unanswered. Plus the anger Harry has and the fact that ew lost someone so special, it was such an emotional journey as a reader.

oh my, i LOVED ootp! i can never really pick my favorite HP book, but its definitely up there. i thought it was great, it really gave us an idea of how the final two books are going to be like...

I loved this last book!! I've read it in 4 days, I couldn't stop!!!
I cried when Sirius died, what a petty, he was one of my favourite characters!!!!
But i still love it!!!

:wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub:

the first time i read it, i couldnt put it down...it was so awesome

Blah, because my father is queer it took me until 2 or so on Saturday of the 21st to get it...but wow it was worth the wait.

I think I finnished it on Sunday at about the same time, I loved it so much. I remember about 100 pages before the end I came running upstairs to my Mum in hysterics I was bawling so badly. Sirius's death shocked the heck out of me, I seriously couldn't stop crying. She was like, "Oh, my God, what happened?" and I'm just like "S-S-Sirius d-d-d-d-died." It was pathetic. I am the biggest loser...seriously.

But apart from being really angry at that horrible Umbridge woman, I honestly adored the book. PoA is still my favorite and it would take something huge in one of the later books to change that.

My favorite part of the whole thing, however is when Harry goes into the Pensieve and sees Lily and James. I love learning about them and the Maurader's, which explains why I enjoy PoA so much.

There was so much going on in OotP that even after a third read I don't think I've caught it all. Perhaps I'll re-read it on the way to Hawaii, God only knows I'll have enough time.

My opinion was that it was sheer brilliance, I loved it. I laughed, cried, yelled, felt happy, felt sad, felt pissed and a million other things, a writing ability only JKR can produce. *sigh* I can't wait till the 6th one.

<3

i was the same way! i read it with my two best friends, brooke and brittney, and we were all crying together. aww, it was awful. i loved sirius. i was hysterical during Prisoner of Azkaban (the movie) when he was saying goodbye to harry before he rode off on buckbeak...i think i'm still in denial over his death.

Wow, yeah did the same exact thing!

I cried three times throughout the movie.

yay for patheticness.

<3

OotP was the best book. In singapore, I was one of those who got the book right early in the morning.

The moment i got it, i started reading it....

I almost broke down crying.. Sirius was one of my favorite characters.. and I will miss his presence in the next two books to be released..

She killed him off for a reason, I know it.. hopefully something good will come out of it all.. (I doubt it, but it's good to shoot for high hopes!)



-Remus

i really like this book because it explain a lot.i can't wait to read the 6th and 7th book now. :bounce: :banana2:

my fav book lol...duel between dumbledore and voldemort=awsome!!

I know! I love the whole action sequence in the Ministry of Magic...it's such a suspenseful and exciting part. I was reading it and I kept shutting my eyes, scared to read what was going to happen next...I can't wait for the sixth one. It's going to be awesome...

OMG! This is probably my 2nd favorite book. I didn't like it because of Sirius...well u know. He is my favorite character, and I hope they bring him back somehow. But I still liked it with Harry and Cho <snicker> and all of the other funny parts.

Grr...why do people like Sirius so much? He never actually did anything....


The same people that's fav charectors are Hedwig i'm sure...



Awsome book...

I never Said I didn't like the Book. I like it, When Sirius Died, I thought it was sad. And Why wouldn't Sirius be somebodies Fav. Character? He is cool! Anywho, Don't dis Characters.


:ravenclaw:

Well sure i loved his charcter...but if u think about it he never did anything...

::looks utterly appalled:: Sure, he didn't do anything...unless you count his spending twelve years in Azkaban for a crime he never committed and saving Harry's life...

Alot of people save his life....anyway we never see him spending the time in azkaban...

I'm just saying ALOT of fic authors make too big a deal over sirius dieing...like harry becoming mass depressed or w.e...

Well Sirius Was the only family that Harry ever knew. Yeah there's the Dursley's but Harry hates them. So yeah harry would be depressed if His family died.

Yeah, Sirius was kind of like a substitute father for Harry. He finally, after so many years of thinking the Dursleys were his only relations, found another family member. They weren't blood relatives (well, that we know of), but it was still a pleasant experience for Harry to be able to have an adult he could turn to. Now, with Sirius's death, Harry probably will become somewhat depressed because it was almost like losing a parent again. Plus, he'll probably feel like its partially his fault...

I LOVE THE BOOK! Only I ordered it through my school and HAD TO WAIT 1 WEEK AFTER THE RELEASE DATE TO GET IT! Rrrrrrrrgh! Anyway, my stupid friend told me Sirius died before I read it ... I was so sad and angry I nearly cried then. But I cried when I read about him dying anyway. Stupid friend ... I HATE HER!

I'm going to miss Sirius.. I liked the book very much :(

Yes Yes Yes I loved It It is my favorite book so far!

Yep, OOTP was absolutely wonderful to me! I loved the part where they formed Dumbledore's Army, and the part afterwards when Dumbledore found out about it. He must have been so proud! The 5th book rocked...

It was a very good book1 but it was sooooooo sad to see sirius die

well, i still think sirius will live as a portrait. somewhere

I love the OWLs part ... Hermione was so funny; the way she kept snapping at people. It reminded me so much of me ...

I must admit, I dreaded reading the end of OotP, but it was an excellent book, I just think I was using it as a comparison to Goblet of Fire (which is my favorite HP), which was not fair on my part.

I thought it was realy good.

Yeah I loved the Order of the Pheonix but I think there should be thousands of people in the Order
and the D.A. should be more public

:Accio_Firebolt:

:hagrid-Norbert:

If it went public Voldamort is more likly to find out were it is and stuff.

Order of the Phoenix was pretty good but personally I thought the first few chapters were ZZZZzzzzzzzz

I think it was the second best of the lot so far.

I think this book is sooooo good but I cryd soooooo hard whaen Sirius *glup* died :no: It was soooooo awful! I couldnt stand it! i STILL cry whenever I hear his name! :cry:

It was okay, but HBP is better!

The book is awesome! I love the fact its so big! lol